Crisp Tater Tot Pickle Salad in striped bowl, surrounded by Ayoh! Dill Pickle Mayo, Garlic & Friends seasoning, Double Dill pickles, and lemon slices.

Tater Tot Pickle Salad

A fresh spin on potato salad — tots meet creamy dill dressing with a briny pickle kick.

Ingredients

Potato salad walked so this tot salad could run. Golden smashed tater tots get drenched in a creamy, garlicky dill dressing with briny pickle bites in every forkful. It’s indulgent, a little unhinged, and guaranteed to disappear at any party.

This isn’t a side dish that sits politely on the table — it’s a main event. Every bite has a bit of double dill magic that keeps you coming back for more. Think of it as potato salad’s louder, alter ego who knows how to have a good time (and always brings the pickles). 

Overhead view of Crisp Tater Tot Pickle Salad with Double Dill pickles, Dill Pickle Mayo, and Garlic & Friends seasoning on a bright green background.

Recipe Instructions:

  1. Preheat oven to 425°F and bake tater tots for 15 minutes until they’re dark golden-brown.
  2. Smash each tot with the bottom of a cup into little golden discs, then bake another 20 minutes until deeply crisp. Remove and let cool completely.
  3. In a large bowl, whisk together Greek yogurt, mayo, lemon juice, garlic, seasoning blend, brine, and scallions.
  4. Gently toss the crispy tots with the dressing, then fold in the dill and diced pickles.
  5. Serve immediately — preferably with extra pickles on the side. 
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!
ALL THINGS PICKLES!