Before getting into specific picks, it helps to understand why cut and format can make or break sandwich pickles. A spear sitting on the side of a plate is one thing. But a pickle that lives between the bread, contributing flavor and texture to every bite, is a completely different conversation.
Thin slices and chips distribute flavor evenly without creating an overwhelming layer. Meanwhile, crinkle cuts hold condiments and add satisfying texture contrast. In contrast, thick slices add more brine flavor per bite. That said, knowing what role you want your pickle to play will point you toward the right format faster than anything else.
The Best Sliced Pickles For Burgers And Sandwiches
Here's our lineup of the best sandwich pickles, organized by flavor profile so you can match the right one to whatever you're building.
The Classic Deli Pick
For classic deli-style flavor, the Classic NYC Deli Pickle by Frankie's Fine Brine is the gold standard. Briny, bold, and halved for a satisfying bite, the half-sour brine gives these a bright, tangy quality that works beautifully on any cold sandwich, deli build, or grilled creation where you want assertive pickle flavor without anything competing with the other ingredients.
The Best Hamburger Pickles In Our Lineup
These are the best hamburger pickles in our lineup, full stop. The Crinkle Dill Pickle Chips from our own Jarred Collection expertly grip the bun and condiments, stay in place through every bite, and provide that crave-worthy crunch that flat-cut chips sometimes miss. There’s pretty much zero chance you’ll have just one, so feel free to stack them generously.
The Everyday Sandwich Staples
To start, the Garlic Dill Pickles by The People's Provisions bring a more confident flavor presence than a standard dill slice. Made with garlic, dill, black peppercorn, and mustard seed, the garlic note adds a savory depth that levels up simple sandwiches, especially on anything with a rich protein like roasted chicken, pulled pork, or a thick-cut patty.
For the sandwich builder who wants dill flavor front and center rather than a background note, Double Dills from our Jarred Collection give you exactly that. We doubled the dill because you deserve it. The herbaceous intensity makes these a great choice for anyone who finds standard dill pickles too mild.
Sandwich Pickles By Flavor Profile
Different sandwiches call for different pickle personalities. Here’s how to match them up.
For Deli-Style Builds
Classic dill and garlic dill pickles belong on any traditional sandwich. Garlic Dill Pickles by The People's Provisions and the Classic NYC Deli Pickle by Frankie's Fine Brine are both excellent choices here. The flavor is familiar and direct without pulling the sandwich in an unexpected direction.
For Sweet And Salty Builds
Bread & Butter Pickle Chips from The People's Provisions are the move for any sandwich where a little sweetness would improve the overall balance. Fried chicken sandwiches, pulled pork, and turkey clubs all benefit from the sweet-salty contrast, with an added savory hit from onion and spices that these pickles provide. Plus, the crinkle cut keeps things tidy and distributes that flavor evenly across every bite.
For Spicy Builds
Sweet and Spicy Pickles and Spicy Garlic Pickles by The People's Provisions both earn a place on sandwiches that can handle the heat. The Sweet and Spicy Pickles start with a smooth sweetness and end with a delightfully fiery finish that will keep you coming for seconds, whereas the thick-cut Spicy Garlic Pickles are exceptional on anything hearty enough to stand up to three types of chiles that don’t hold back. Both add a sharp dimension that kicks every bite up a notch.
Recipes That Put Your Sandwich Pickles To Work
A great pickle deserves an equally amazing sandwich, and we have a few recipes worth trying that put these pickles exactly where they belong. To start, the Crunchwrap Pickle Cravewich is built around pickle flavor as a central element rather than a garnish, and it delivers in a big way. Use the Crinkle Dill Pickle Chips or the Garlic Dill Pickles for the best results.
For something unexpected that actually works, the Spicy and Sweet Pickle Peanut Butter Sandwich pairs sweet heat pickle flavor with creamy peanut butter in a combination that sounds strange until you try it. The Sweet and Spicy Pickles are the perfect match here.
From there, the Pickle Chip Sliders are a crowd-pleasing favorite that showcases crinkle-cut pickle chips at their best, and the Pickle Hot Dogs Platter is the kind of spread where great sandwich pickles get to shine in a different format entirely.
Stocking Your Sandwich Pickle Collection
The best sandwich experience comes from having options. A classic dill for traditional builds, a sweet chip for the days you want something different, and a spicy slice for bolder builds covers most situations well. Our Build a Pickle Box lets you mix and match exactly the sandwich pickles you want so your fridge is always stocked. Pick your profiles, build your box, and never build a boring sandwich again.
Stocking Your Sandwich Pickle Collection
The best sandwich experience comes from having options. A classic dill for traditional builds, a sweet chip for days when you want something milder, and a spicy slice for bold burgers cover most situations well. Our Build a Pickle Box option lets you mix and match the precise sandwich pickles you want, so your fridge is always stocked. Pick your faves, create your lineup, and never make a boring sandwich again.
