Kilhaney's Pickles makes handcrafted pickles that go somewhere unexpected without losing sight of what makes a great pickle in the first place: crunch, brine, and a flavor profile that earns repeat purchases. We carry two of their standout options.
Freaky Tiki Pickle
Freaky Tiki Pickle by Kilhaney's Pickles is the gourmet artisan pickle that converts people who claim they don't like sweet pickles. Made from cucumbers, pineapple, vinegar, sugar, brown sugar, apple cider vinegar, and a blend of spices in a 16oz package, this is a sweet-savory combination that delivers an unforgettable flavor with a vibrant, tangy finish. The pineapple doesn't overpower the cucumber; it lifts it. Two verified buyers gave it five stars, one simply saying "SO GOOD!" which is about as honest a review as a pickle can get. This is the best artisan pickle to reach for when you want something that surprises people in the best possible way.
Garlic Dillicious Pickles
Garlic Dillicious Pickles by Kilhaney's Pickles is the handcrafted pickle for garlic lovers who want a fresh-forward brine rather than a heavy, muted one. Cucumbers, garlic, water, vinegar, apple cider vinegar, salt, dill, and spices in a 16oz package make for a clean, punchy flavor that puts garlic at the front without any artificial edge. One verified buyer rated it four stars and called it "good flavor," which for a garlic dill pickle is exactly the outcome you want: a reliable, repeat-purchase artisan pickle that delivers what the name promises. Browse the full Pickles and Pickled Products collection for the complete range of handcrafted and artisan options we carry.
Beyond Cucumbers: Gourmet Artisan Pickles In Unexpected Forms
The best artisan pickle brands don't stop at cucumbers. Some of the most exciting handcrafted pickles in our lineup use unexpected base ingredients and layered spice blends that take the format somewhere entirely new.
Spiced Watermelon Pickles by Pickled Pink
Spiced Watermelon Pickles by Pickled Pink is the gourmet artisan pickle that makes people pause before they even open the package. Watermelon rind pickled with ginger, cinnamon, allspice, clove, and mustard seed in a 16 fl oz package for a warm, rich, spiced flavor profile that plays nicely alongside sweet, savory, or spicy dishes. One verified buyer said they were "pleasantly surprised" and noted the warm cinnamon character pairs best alongside other flavors rather than on its own, exactly the kind of nuanced use case among the best artisan pickles in our lineup. Check availability at the link.
Pumpernickel Ry-Ry Bread & Butter Pickles by Backyard Brine
Pumpernickel Ry-Ry Bread & Butter Pickles by Backyard Brine is the handcrafted pickle that takes the classic bread and butter format and adds molasses, maple syrup, and crushed caraway to the brine for a bold, earthy sweetness that earns its own conversation. Made from cucumbers, vinegar, cane sugar, cider vinegar, onion, brown sugar, organic molasses, maple syrup, caraway, mustard seed, and celery seed in a 16oz package. It's 100% all-natural, sugar-free labeling-wise, fat-free, vegan, and made in the USA. The pumpernickel rye character gives the brine a depth that a standard bread and butter pickle simply can't replicate. These are the artisan pickles for the sandwich builder, the charcuterie board curator, and anyone who takes their sweet pickle seriously.
Classic Deli Done Right: Frankie's Fine Brine And The NYC Artisan Standard
Some of the best artisan pickle brands earn their reputation by doing the classic formats better than anyone else rather than chasing novelty. Frankie's Fine Brine falls squarely in that category.
Classic NYC Deli Pickle by Frankie's Fine Brine
Classic NYC Deli Pickle by Frankie's Fine Brine is the handcrafted pickle that exists to answer a simple question: what does a great New York deli pickle actually taste like? Bold garlic, fresh dill, and a properly seasoned vinegar brine in a format that holds its crunch and delivers a genuinely classic kosher dill flavor that you don't find at the grocery store. This is the gourmet artisan pickle for the purist, the person who wants the real thing rather than something clever or unexpected. The Best Pickle Brands 2026 blog post is the companion read for anyone building their knowledge of the artisan pickle landscape and wanting to see how Frankie's Fine Brine fits into the broader picture.
Artisan Pickled Vegetables: Smokin' Okra And Carrots Of Fire
Artisan pickles don't belong exclusively to cucumbers. Pickled Pink and Pacific Pickle Works both bring the same small-batch sensibility to vegetables that deserve it just as much.
Smokin' Okra by Pickled Pink
Smokin' Okra by Pickled Pink is the artisan pickled vegetable that earns its place on any board or Bloody Mary skewer through bold smoky character, turmeric-forward brine color, and the kind of snap that fresh okra in a proper brine delivers. Chili pepper flakes and an extract of turmeric give this 16 fl oz package a distinctive look and a heat note that keeps every bite interesting. This is the handcrafted pickle for anyone who wants their pickled vegetable lineup to go somewhere beyond the expected.
"Carriots of Fire" Carrots by Pacific Pickle Works
"Carriots of Fire" Carrots by Pacific Pickle Works brings organic carrots, apple cider vinegar, jalapeño, onion, garlic, organic raw sugar, and spices together for a sweet-spicy fire carrot that earns its name one bite at a time. Pacific Pickle Works makes small-batch, boldly seasoned pickled vegetables that sit comfortably alongside the best artisan pickle brands in the cucumber category. These belong on a board, a snack spread, or alongside any of the handcrafted pickles above for a full artisan pickled spread. Browse our The Pickle Factory Pickles collection for our own house pickled products alongside these artisan brands, and check our Value Bundles for curated multi-pack options. For anyone building a gifting spread around these handcrafted finds, our Pickle Gifts collection is the place to start.